Archive for the ‘Technology’ Category

The hilariously epic failure of Orange voice recognition

Thursday, April 19th, 2012

I tried to activate a new Orange pre-paid SIM today by phone. It went a little bit like this (starting from trying to enter my flat number):

Orange robot: “Please say the number of your flat”
Me: “Five”
Orange robot: “I’m sorry. I couldn’t understand that. Please say the number of your flat”
Me: “FIVE”
Orange robot: “Is this correct? Flat eight…”
Me: “No”
Orange robot: “Please say the number of your flat”
Me: “Five”
Orange robot: “I’m sorry. I couldn’t understand that. Please say the number of your flat”
Me: “FIVE”
Orange robot: “Is this correct? Flat eight…”
Me: “No”
Orange robot: “Please say the number of your flat”
Me: “Five”
Orange robot: “I’m sorry. I couldn’t understand that. Please say the number of your flat”
Me: “FIVE”
Orange robot: “Is this correct? Flat eight…”
Me: “No”
Orange robot: “I’m sorry, I’m having problems understanding you. I’ll transfer you to an operator.”

Orange robot: “Sorry, you don’t have enough credit for this operation. Calls to operators are charged at 25p per minute”

(Click, hang up, try again… and yet again I stumble at the same point)

Orange robot: “Please say the number of your flat”
Me: “Fiiivvve”
Orange robot: “I’m sorry. I couldn’t understand that. Please say the number of your flat”
Me: “FFFIIIVVEEE”
Orange robot: “Is this correct? Flat eight…”
Me: “NO”

(Gives phone to partner, whom speaks better English than me it seems, the address is finally accepted.)

Orange robot: “OK, please say your last name”

(This concerns me. My last name is very simple — just “Offer”. Yet it’s surprising how often people get this wrong. In fact hardly ever do people get it right first off. But I reassure myself: my last name isn’t Muralitharan or anything too tongue-twisting)

Me: “Offer”
Orange robot: “Did you say, ‘Awful’?”
Me: (muffled hysteria)
Orange robot: “I’m sorry, I couldn’t understand that. Is your last name correct?”
Me: NO!
Orange robot: “OK, please say your last name”
Me: “OOFFEERRR”
Orange robot: “Did you say, ‘Arthur’?”

(Click, hang up and give up)

And this is why I think voice recognition is one of the worst forms of interaction ever — any experience that leaves me wondering if I’m in an episode of Fonejacker is not a good one.

Has Apple really killed the PC?

Saturday, August 20th, 2011

Brent Rose at Gizmodo wrote a brilliant piece on HP’s withdrawl from the PC market yesterday entitled Hey PC Makers: Don’t Quit, Fight!. (The sub headline is even better: GROW A PAIR).

Hamsters are directly responsible for the demise of PCs
Perhaps hamsters are directly responsible for the demise of PCs?

To me, there’s one simple and incredibly obvious reason Apple is indeed killing the PC market. It’s a combination of simplicity and clear product definition. Everyone knows the iPhone, the iPad and hell even the MacBook Pro. And iMac. You want a phone? That’s the iPhone. A tablet computer? iPad. A laptop? Yep, MacBook Pro.

Now let’s look at HP.

(more…)